Snow Goose Overpopulation Essay Research Paper The

Snow Goose Overpopulation Essay, Research Paper

The Overpopulation of the Snow Goose in North America

Abstraction

The intent of this paper is to research available research on the overpopulation of the Snow Goose on the North American continent. The snow goose has been lifting in population since the center of the century and has been intensifying so much it is destructing their natural home ground. Wildlife directors have merely late begun to implement schemes to battle this job. Chiefly through the usage of huntsmans the directors are seeking to control the population growing.

Introduction

There are three chief species of Snow Goose of primary concern. The Lesser Snow Goose ( LSGO ) is the must abundant and at the same clip most troublesome. Ross? Goose ( ROGO ) is really similar to the Lesser and can merely be distinguished by close observation. Both the Lesser and the Ross nest in salt fens along Hudson Bay and so migrate down to the gulf seashore provinces such as Texas and Louisiana. Their populations figure in the 1000000s. The 3rd bomber species is the Greater Snow Goose. They nest in the same fens as the others except they migrate down the Atlantic Coast into the Carolinas and that locality. All three species have exploded in Numberss since the 1950? s. Research workers have done a batch of survey on the Numberss and the debasement but may necessitate to make more surveies on the impact to other species and expression for other options to command the populations.

Population Tendencies

The Numberss of all “ light ” colored geese has been on the rise since information was foremost collected. The Lesser Snow Goose ( LSGO ) has drastically increased in figure since information was foremost taken. Numbers range from around 800,000 in 1969 to every bit many as 6 million in 1996 ( CWS 1999 ) . While the Greater Snow Goose ( GSGO ) has risen in Numberss from a few 1000 to about 500,000 ( CWS 1999 ) . This brief article did non supply much insight into existent Numberss. Abraham and Jeffries in their study dig deeper and supply more important and elaborate population counts. Their Numberss add in the Mid-winter index, which is the figure of geese counted during mid-winter and referred to as MWI. Their Numberss besides have a count for Ross? Goose ( ROGO ) which chiefly flies with the ( LSGO ) and is really difficult to separate ( Abraham and Jeffries 1998 ) . They excessively suggest the LSGO population to be about 800,000 in 1969 and in 1994 about 2.4 million. Although it is suggested that the figure is low due an undercount during the winter and a more precise count may be taken when nesting in spring. The population of Greater Snow Goose has reached 612,000 from around 50,000 in the mid 1960? s. Ross? Goose has increased from 8,000 in 1957 to about 500,000 in 1995 ( Abraham and Jeffries ) . The Texas Department of Fish and Wildlife provinces that the population of wintering snow geese has remained changeless. They imply this is due to the fact that the geese have spread their winter scope into other provinces ( TWDS 1999 ) . As indicated earlier it is really difficult to number wintering birds because such a big figure of wintering countries. Below are a few graphs of these population tendencies

( CWS 1999 )

( Ingstrup 98 )

( Ingstrup 1998 )

Factors lending to High Population

The snow goose job is a wildlife director & # 8217 ; s incubus. Through prudent limitations on birds taken as game, and the addition in safeties coupled with first-class home ground in the birds full scope. It is estimated that there is about 900,000 hour angle of rice Fieldss over the snow goose? s winter scope ( Abraham and Jeffries 1998 ) . This is in add-on to the typical salt fen wintering land. Abraham and Jeffries suggest that farther to the North in provinces like Nebraska and North Dakota the transition of grassland prairie into cereal grains has provided a enormous sum of nutrient for the geese. In add-on it has besides blurred the country typically considered the wintering scope. It may besides supply a natural remainder halt along the manner for migrating birds guaranting greater wellness at nesting evidences ( Abraham and Jeffries 1998 ) . The constitution of refugees has reduced the sum of birds taken by huntsmans leting more birds to finish a full migration rhythm ( CWS 1999 ) . Hunting of the Greater Snow Goose was banned in the us from 1931-75 ( Abraham and Jeffries 1998 ) . Hunting was non allowed to advance population Numberss, and one time started in 1975 did non hold a high crop. The LSGO and ROGO get downing in the center of the 60? s and continually hold extended their nesting scope south into less utmost clime ( Abraham and Jeffries 1998 ) . It has besides been suggested that since birds are now populating longer the older grownups are now taking the less wary immature to safer sites and out of huntsman & # 8217 ; s scope ( Ingstrup 1998 ) . Ingstrup besides suggests that the artic may be warming and as Abraham and Jeffries cited there has been shown a correlativity between the snow thaw and endurance of nesting birds and their immature. Harmonizing to Hodge the one-year putting to death by huntsmans in 1970 neared 40 % but in 1994 the rate had dropped to less than 8 % . Therefore leting a great trade of the grownup population to return to nesting sites in the spring.

Impact on home ground

The snow geese still nest in a chiefly salt marsh environment. The geese have a damaging eating behaviour in which they pull up the fen grass by the roots. This behaviour is know as grubbing and when done in mass measures can destruct whole fens for decennaries. A undertaking known as the “ Hudson B

ay Undertaking: Ecosystem Studies and Conservation of Coastal Arctic Tundra ” has done extended research onto the effects of the snow goose population on the country around Hudson Bay. Researchers there estimate that it takes decennaries to replace a fen that has been decimated by the geese. It has been shown by the Hudson Bay Project that repeated mooching on the salt fen in the Hudson Bay country has efficaciously depleted a big per centum of the available fen. The geese wholly strip the fen of grass, and can destroy a fen for a long period of clip. The undertaking research workers set up exclusion zones where they fenced off portion of the fen to show and mensurate the effects of grubbing and overpopulation on fens. The exclusion zone would keep green spot of grass while the remainder of the fen would go wastes and unwanted ( Hudson Bay Project 1999 ) . Some have suggested they are damaging the harvests in their winter scope, but it is besides known that a big part of their winter nutrient is waste grain, non a immense environmental impact as in their nesting evidences. It is estimated about 35 per centum of their nesting district has been wholly destroyed and another 30 per centum so severely damaged that is non feasible and the staying 35 per centum is in sedate danger of going wasted ( Hodge 1999 ) .

Exclusion zones demoing marsh grass depletion. ( Hudson Bay Project )

Degraded fen. ( Hudson Bay Project )

Impact on other Speciess

The impact on other species is the major whole I have seen in the research done to day of the month, I had a existent difficult clip happening any concrete grounds that the high figure of geese was negatively impacting other species. The Hudson Bay Project and Hodge both claim that it is and will impact other species such as ducks and shore birds. While it might be easy to pull the decision that degrading of their home ground will direct the populations into diminution I merely wear? t see much difficult grounds, and it would be nice in future surveies to hold a correlativity between the addition in Snow goose population and a lessening in say the xanthous rail population. Abraham and Jeffries make and first-class point “ The graduated table of the job and associated degree of hazard to the broader populations requires intensive survey, including some computation of the proportion of entire scope of the species affected by goose harm. It is clear, nevertheless, that the interaction is dynamic, and the rapid business of new countries by geese additions the menace to other species even as the effects are being calculated. ”

Management Schemes

The general consensus among many groups is that a really big per centum of the population needs to be eliminated. There are two chief ways now that birds a killed. That is through Aboriginal egging and Recreational hunting. The sum to which hunting is disputed ( Paul 1999 ) . Paul points to apparently different Numberss by two different groups each proposing the recommended putting to death or crop of the Snow goose. Mrs. Paul besides points out that on the utmost terminal the crop rate would hold to increase by 9 crease to hold the coveted consequence on the overall population. To hold this desired consequence the US and Canadian authoritiess have agreed to spread out runing in hopes of nabbing more birds. Texas even has proposed a particular license for some huntsmans that would let them to take every bit many as 100 more birds than they did last twelvemonth. The Canadian authorities is besides looking into ways to promote Aboriginal peoples to take more eggs for subsistence. States are being encouraged to make what is necessary to increase runing chances for the Snow goose. Some are sing seting force per unit area on private land proprietors to let more hunting. Refugee directors are besides dallying with opening up more hunting on antecedently denoted safe zones. Manitoba has opened up a particular Lesser Snow Goose runing season in the spring and allowed huntsmans to utilize electronic calls ( CWS 1999 ) . Electronic calls are thought to increase the opportunities for huntsmans.

Will it Work?

One of the chief concerns for all involved is will it work? Paul stresses the point that we must see if the schemes will let for complete recovery of the grass. Should the Refuge system be modified? Are our patterns for other migratory birds traveling to take to similar jobs? ( Paul 1999 ) It is estimated that huntsmans will necessitate to kill over 900,000 geese a twelvemonth for over a decennary to do any sort of dent in the population ( Hodge 1999 ) . Some are disbelieving that huntsmans can take that many birds to get down with, allow entirely the fact that to many that seems like a unmerciful slaughter of guiltless animate beings.

Decision

It appears that one thing is really clear? there is an overpopulation of Snow Geese on the North American Continent. The state of affairs is about out of manus and something demands to be done fast. Although there has adequate research on the fact that there are merely to many geese there truly has non been plenty on the impacts to other species, and what is the best manner to take attention of the job. Both the US and the Canadian authorities seem to be on the right way to commanding this job that worlds have created. But more demands to be done. There merely merely isn? t adequate huntsmans around to take the proper sum of birds in a clean mode. Wildlife directors are traveling to hold to step in and take more extremist step to command this before its excessively late and we have lost all the home ground for the geese and all other dwellers of the salt fens of the Hudson Bay country.

339