Nathaniel HawthorneS The Birthmark Essay Research Paper

Nathaniel Hawthorne? S? The Birthmark? Essay, Research Paper

Man & # 8217 ; s Handss

In Nathaniel Hawthorne & # 8217 ; s short narrative & # 8220 ; The Birthmark, & # 8221 ; there are many positions on the demand for scientific discipline and its progresss. Hawthorne & # 8217 ; s supporter, Aylmer, illustrates his ain personal appraisal of scientific discipline. The narrative is based on the thought that scientific discipline can work out all of humanistic disciplines ailments and jobs. Hawthorne believes that scientific discipline is infesting life. Aylmer is consumed by his passion of overtake Mother Nature. The narrative shows how Aylmer & # 8217 ; s passion leads to non merely his ruin but that of his married woman Georgiana every bit good. The belief that scientific discipline can work out and make anything is one of ignorance because it wholly disregards the human component of spiritualty.

The thought of hubris, which is a Grecian word significance inordinate pride of a person who believes they are on the degree of the Gods, is really evident in the narrative. In Ancient Greek myths, the Gods normally punished those who acted with hubris. Aylmer, himself, believes that he is on the degree of the Gods. This is shown in the transition & # 8220 ; Aylmer possessed this grade of religion in adult male & # 8217 ; s ultimate control over Nature & # 8221 ; ( 44 ) . Aylmer & # 8217 ; s chesty belief that he can prevail over Nature can be found when he and Georgiana, are speaking about the remotion of the nevus: & # 8220 ; & # 8216 ; what will be my victory when I shall hold corrected what Nature left progressive in her fairest work & # 8217 ; & # 8221 ; ( 47 ) . Near the terminal Aylmer is so certain that he has beaten Nature that he mocks it: & # 8220 ; & # 8216 ; Ah ball! ah, earthly mass & # 8217 ; & # 8221 ; ( 55 ) . This shows Aylmer & # 8217 ; s haughtiness because it shows that he believes that he is The Creator. Aylmer & # 8217 ; s psychotic beliefs of magnificence are crushed at the terminal when Georgiana dies. He is, so to talk, struck down by the Gods.

In the chase of scientific find, Hawthorne raises the inquiry of when is adequate, plenty? Where should the proverbial line be drawn? Aylmer is ever endeavoring for absolute control over the Natural World. Hawthorne develops the character of Aminadab to function this intent. Aminadab is the perfect contrast to Aylmer. Aminadab & # 8220 ; seemed to stand for adult male & # 8217 ; s physical nature ; while Aylmer & # 8217 ; s slender figure, and picket, rational face, were no less apt a religious component & # 8221 ; ( 48 ) . Aminadab realizes that Georgiana is so perfect the manner she is, and should non be tampered with. This is shown in a quotation mark from Aminadab, & # 8220 ; & # 8216 ; if she were my married woman, I & # 8217 ; d ne’er portion with that nevus & # 8217 ; & # 8221 ; ( 48 ) . He realizes scientific discipline can non catch Mother Nature. Aylmer & # 8217 ; s position towards it is one of disgust. He thinks & # 8220 ; it will be such a ecstasy to take it & # 8221 ; ( 48 ) . This shows the contrast of the work forces, Aminadab and Aylmer. When Aminadab chuckles the & # 8221 ; hoarse, chortling laugh, & # 8221 ; ( 55 ) at the terminal of the narrative, it truly drives Hawthorne & # 8217 ; s point place. That is, it is absurd to believe that scientific discipline can work out all of life & # 8217 ; s enigmas.

Aylmer’s book of experiments and their consequences is a metaphor for how scientific find merely leads us to happen more inquiries non replies. In Aylmer’s book, it shows that all his great accomplishments and finds were simply accidents and byproducts of his original ends that failed to accomplish conclusive replies: “his most glorious successes were most constantly failures, if compared with the ideal at which he aimed” ( 51 ) . It becomes evident to the reader that all of Aylmer’s efforts were simply ineffectual and in vain. “ ‘The mixture of the draft has been perfect, ’ said he, in reply to Georgiana’s expression. ‘Unless all my scientific discipline have deceived me, it can non fail’ ” ( 54 ) .

Alas, the draft is far from perfect, all of Aylmer & # 8217 ; s scientific discipline has deceived him and his ultimate failure comes to fruition as Georgiana dies. Aylmer is but a mere adult male.

The hand-like nevus on Georgiana & # 8217 ; s face symbolizes her mortal imperfectness that kept the brotherhood between spiritualty and mortality. Hawthorne & # 8217 ; s review of scientific discipline relates with this because it shows the peculiarity between what scientific discipline deems as life and how life is seen through the eyes of spiritualty. Science sees the nevus as an imperfectness that can be removed. This can be seen in the words of Aylmer, & # 8220 ; & # 8216 ; I am convinced of the perfect practicableness of its remotion & # 8217 ; & # 8221 ; ( 46 ) . This is the scientist & # 8217 ; s position of Aylmer that believes adult male is capable of exceeding anyone or anything. Spiritualty on the other manus positions the nevus as an object of necessity: & # 8220 ; some faery at her birth hr had laid her bantam manus upon the baby & # 8217 ; s cheek & # 8221 ; ( 44 ) . The nevus is the imperfectness that keeps Georgiana on the existent universe and non in the religious 1. Aylmer & # 8217 ; s inability to understand that scientific discipline can non catch spiritualty instead than the fact that scientific discipline merely helps to understand the religious facet of life can be best summed up in the transition: & # 8220 ; & # 8216 ; My peerless bride. It is successful! You are perfect & # 8217 ; & # 8221 ; ( 55 ) . This absolutely shows that, although scientific discipline can repair something, it can non understand that it is mending.

Will science, and the farther development of engineering suffice to take the topographic point of Nature? Will it replace God in the human head? Hawthorne leaves these inquiries open for the reader to chew over. Possibly, it is the pure simpleness of life that Aminadab suggests in the narrative that will take humankind to true felicity. Aylmer pursued apparently impossible undertakings that merely farther complicated his life, and necessarily destroyed his ain spirit through the decease of his married woman Georgiana. & # 8220 ; Alas! It was excessively true! The fatal manus had grappled with the enigma of life, and was the bond by which an angelic spirit kept itself in brotherhood with a mortal frame & # 8221 ; ( 55 ) .

Bibliography

Short Story & # 8220 ; The Birthmark & # 8221 ; by Nathaniel Hawthorne

350