Who Or What Is To Blame For

The Tragedy Of & # 8216 ; Romeo And Juliet & # 8217 ; Essay, Research Paper

The deceases of

Romeo and Juliet appear needless, as it was chiefly the people around them who

were contending and differing about the relationship. Romeo and Juliet chiefly

kept out of the contending but their lives were made suffering and unhappy by the

people around them who were interfering, and because they were so profoundly in

love with each other, they refused to be split up and hence took hazards to

stay together which finally led to their deceases. The Prologue at the

beginning of the drama suggests it was chiefly destiny that was to fault,

? star-cross? vitamin D lovers and? death-mark? vitamin D love? are illustrations of this. ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Romeo is a immature adolescent, a member of the Montague

family, who unluckily falls in love with Juliet, a Capulet whose household

are acrimonious enemies of the Montagues. He blames Fate or bad luck for about

everything that goes incorrect ; after he kills Tybalt, he so realises the

earnestness of his action but prefers to fault the stars instead than himself. ? O, I am fortune? s sap? . I think killing

Tybalt was the biggest error Romeo made as it led to his ostracism and it

meant he could no longer see his darling Juliet, without the hazard of being

caught. I do non believe though that you can fault Romeo for killing Tybalt as he

was determined to contend Romeo and when he refused, Romeo? s closest friend

Mercutio stepped in and drew his blade. They fought and Romeo intervenes seeking

to halt them but this harmonizing to the deceasing Mercutio gave Tybalt the chance

to kill him, ? I was hurt under your arm? . Romeo so fought and killed Tybalt.

Subsequently when he hears from Balthasar the intelligence that Juliet is dead he says, ? Then

I defy you stars? , intending he is non traveling to allow Fate order what happens to

him any longer. It seems that

Romeo is either non afraid to take hazards or merely doesn? t think about any of his

actions, in the balcony scene he risks acquiring caught by the Nurse, and so

subsequently in Juliet? s sleeping room when Lady Capulet is looking for her. Juliet is a immature

Capulet non rather 14 old ages old, she is soft, loyal, obeys her parents and

thinks for herself. When she foremost meets Romeo she falls for him immediately. She

is practical in that she rapidly asks Romeo to get married her which would be against

her parents? will as they want her to get married Paris whom she does non love. She

is besides similar Romeo in that she does non believe of the effect of her

actions. She is loyal to Romeo, as she is worried about him acquiring caught in

the balcony scene? The grove walls are high

and difficult to mount And the topographic point decease,

sing who thou art, ? ( Act 2 Scene 2 ) She is different from Romeo

in the fact that she does non fault destiny for the things that go incorrect, she

blames her birth as we here in these riming pairs? Colossal birth of love is

to me, That I must love a loathed

enemy. ? ( Act 1 Scene 5 ) ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Whereas friends and Friar Laurence talk to and rede

Romeo, Juliet is on her ain and has to do her ain determinations, with the Nurse

offering small or no aid. Romeo? s parents seem really caring and loving, but

Juliet? s parents particularly Lady Capulet are really cold hearted and detached,

they force Juliet into impairing Paris without giving her a pick. ? She shall be

married to this baronial earl? . ( Act 3 Scene 4 ) Juliet visits Friar Laurence and

is pleased to about his programs for herself and Romeo as she is at this clip

distressed at the idea of holding to get married Paris for she says? Oh bid me jump, instead than

marry Paris From of the crenelations of

any tower? . ( Act 4 Scene 1 ) Friar Laurences program for

Romeo and Juliet was that Juliet was to take a potion to do her appear dead

on her nuptials twenty-four hours she would so be taken to the Capulets? vault interim

after having a missive from the Friar Romeo would return to Verona from

Mantua and would be with Juliet when she wakes up. Juliet was really pleased to

have the potion from Friar Laurence? Give me, give me! Oh Tell

me non of fright! ( Act 4 Scene 1 ) The Friar is a

adult male with good purposes but is persuaded to do hazardous determinations by Romeo and

Juliet, such as holding to get married them without their parents? consent. I think

he gets excessively involved and it is so left up to him to guarantee that everything

goes swimmingly as planned. ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? He goes behind the dorsums of Juliet? s parents by holding

to get married Romeo and Juliet but he has a good ground for this. ? To turn your

families rancour to pure love? , to accommodate the two feuding households. Though

the Friar is concerned about what he is making, ? These violent delectations have

violent terminals? , the program to accommodate the households shortly comes to grief as Romeo

is banished. This clip he makes another program that is every bit hazardous as the first.

Romeo is to travel to Mantua where he will so seek to set up a meeting between

Romeo and Juliet. The program goes incorrect and he accuses destiny, ? Unhappy Fortune? . ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Juliet, who now faces the remainder of her life with Paris

bends to the Friar for a solution, he supplies her with a? kiping potion?

which she uses to do it look like she is dead so she does non hold to get married

Paris. I think it is just to state that Friar Laurence is one of the chief people

to fault for the calamity, as it was his programs that went incorrect. But from Romeo

and Juliet? s position he was really helpful and ever had a solution for their

dilemmas The Nurse is one

of Juliet? s closest friends, apart from Romeo. She is non peculiarly clever

or sensitive and does nil to warn Juliet of how

an engagement with a

Montague might do jobs to Juliet and her household. In Act 1 Scene 3 when

Lady Capulet is discoursing the possibility of matrimony to Paris she makes gags

and finds it really diverting, ? A bump every bit large as a immature cockerels rock? . Even

though the Nurse may be really simple minded and chatty she is really loving and

fond of Juliet? Well sir my

kept woman is the sweetest lady? ( Act 2 Scene 4 ) The Nurse

appears to hold got excessively carried off with the state of affairs with Romeo and is eager

for Juliet to get married, but she offers no advice or cautiousness to what Juliet is

making, although she clearly knows that Juliet is immature and inexperient. She

makes no attempt to propose that this will be a job. Like Friar Laurence she

goes behind her employers? dorsums moving as Romeo and Juliet? s courier, such

as when she is asked by Juliet to detect Romeo? s individuality. At first the Nurse

admires Romeo, ? Why he? s a adult male of wax? ( Act 1 Scene 3 ) , but warns him non to

lead Juliet into a? saps Eden? ( Act 2 Scene 4 ) , largely because Juliet is

immature. ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? After Tybalt? s decease she turns against Romeo? Will you

speak good of him that killed your cousin? ( Act 3 Scene 2 ) , ? Shame come to

Romeo? ( Act 3 Scene 2 ) . Finally when Juliet needs the Nurse most? Comfort me,

council me? as her parents state her that she must get married Paris, the Nurse Lashkar-e-Taibas

her down by merely stating her to bury Romeo and marry Paris. It is at this

point that Juliet dismisses the Nurse, stoping their friendly relationship. I think that

the Nurse was partially, to fault. I don? T think she earnestly realised what could

go on if things got out of manus. The Nurse was good intentioned but in her

concerns for Juliet? s public assistance she became really excitable and could non keep her

lingua. Benvolio is one

character who seems to gain the possible dangers such as when he tries to

dissuade Mercutio from get downing another street bash. He besides urges Romeo to

go forth the scene of the combat as he has a good thought of the Prince? s reaction,

the prince enters the scene after the deceases of Mercutio and Tybalt, he shouts

angrily, ? Romeo slew him ; he slew

Mercutio. Who now the monetary value of his

beloved blood doth owe? ? ( Act 3 Scene 1 ) I think Benvolio is non at

all to fault, if anything he really tried to assist the state of affairs ; he is a

conciliator. Tybalt is a hot

tempered and aggressive individual. His position of the Montagues and his portion in the

drama is summed up in one sentence? What, drawn and talk of peace! I hate the word

/As I hate snake pit, all Montagues and thee? ( Act 1 Scene 1 ) . Again at the ball

when he overhears Romeo he is enraged and looks for his blade but is fortunately

stopped. Tybalt is ever looking for problem and will non endorse off, he tries

to do merriment of Romeo by stating things like, ? Romeo, the love I bear thy

can afford No better term than this –

thou art a villain. ? ( Act 3 Scene 1 ) Last, he challenges Romeo

to a affaire d’honneur. Mercutio stairss in but Tybalt is happy to contend him every bit good. Romeo

efforts to screen out the state of affairs peacefully but Tybalt is uninterested. In

his choler over the decease of his beloved friend Mercutio, Romeo takes retaliation and

in his choler putting to deaths Tybalt. I think Tybalt should take some incrimination in the calamity

as it was his actions that killed Mercutio which in bend led to his ain decease

and Romeo? s ostracism. Mercutio is a

lively character who tries to decide Romeo? s jobs and rede him in a

blithe manner, he says to Romeo, ? Thy humor is a

really acrimonious sweeting ; it is a most crisp sauce. ? He is loyal to Romeo in the

manner he steps in when Tybalt challenges Romeo. His decease is a turning point in

the drama as Romeo, so avenges his decease by killing Tybalt. All these deceases

add more fuel to the fire. I think possibly that Mercutio should non hold intervened,

but being that type of individual he did. I do non believe he can be to fault for the

calamity as neither Tybalt nor Mercutio new of Romeo and Juliets love for each

other. Besides Tybalt would likely hold fought Romeo anyhow and one of them

could hold been killed. The Prince is

the swayer of Verona. He tries rather difficult to maintain the peace, but non plenty to

halt the calamity, he is large in his menaces but does non transport them out for & # 8211 ; he

has the opportunity to implement the decease punishment on Romeo. For illustration after the

deceases of Mercutio and Tybalt the Prince tells the citizens of Verona? who now

the monetary value of his beloved blood doth owe? ? ( Act 3 Scene 1 ) in other words he seeks

justness for these slayings. If he had tried harder to forestall the quarrelling

and carried out more of his menaces the feud might non hold got every bit bad as it

did. However at the terminal of the drama he accepts some of the duty for

what has happened by? Winking at their strifes? ( Act 5 Scene 3 ) . He besides tries

to convey the two sides together by, ? What a flagellum is laid upon your hatred,

/that heavens discoveries means to kill your joys with love? ( Act 5 Scene 3 ) . I do non believe

there is one individual individual who is entirely to fault but Friar Laurence plays a

big portion in the calamity, chiefly through his complicated programs, which require

accurate timing, and in the terminal merely did non go on. Romeo did non have

the missive, so when he heard the bad intelligence from Balthasar, he thought Juliet was

truly dead. Friar Laurence need non hold granted the petitions of Romeo and

Juliet without carefully sing the effects. I do non believe destiny

played a portion in the drama as there were excessively many errors made by the chief

characters.By Stephen Bond