Heart Transplant Candidate Essay Sample

The intent of this memoranda is to come to a decision about which single should have the bosom graft taking into history moralss. There are three people who are in demand of the organ graft ; Jerry. Lisa. and Ozzy. In order to do an informed determination it is of import to look at all three instances. Candidate # 1-

Jerry is a 55 twelvemonth old male with three kids. In his early 20’s Jerry used steroids which in bend damaged his bosom. His life anticipation would increase by about 10-15 old ages with this graft. Candidate # 2-

Lisa is a 12 twelvemonth old female. Her bosom was damaged when she contracted pneumonia a twelvemonth ago. Lisa has had wellness jobs all her life due to a lupus-like immune lack. Even with the graft. it is improbable that Lisa will populate through her 20’s. Candidate # 3-

Ozzy is a 38 twelvemonth old male who has a history of drug maltreatment. As a consequence of Ozzy’s drug usage. he will non be able to populate past the month. With the graft Ozzy has the life anticipation of 10+ old ages.

The Rights Theory
The Rights Theory province that an action is ethical is it respects the rights that all persons have. Taking this theory into history. I do non believe it is ethical to accept the 2 million dollars which are being offered to the infirmary in exchange for Lisa to have the graft. All three of the campaigners should hold the same chances and the money is overcasting the issue at manus. The infirmary will non be accepting contributions at this clip. or in the hereafter. for organ grafts. Utilitarianism

Utilitarianism provinces that rightness or inappropriateness of one’s actions is determined by their effects. Using the useful point of position. the bosom should travel to Lisa. She is the youngest of all three campaigners and besides has the potency for a life of illustriousness. Lisa is besides the lone campaigner whose actions did non do her bosom failure. In the instance of both Jerry and Ozzy there was drug maltreatment which caused their bosom conditions. Decision

After researching the useful moralss and looking at the Rights Theory I have come to the decision that the bosom will be granted to Lisa. The infirmary is gracious for the generousness of Lisa’s female parent and male parent. but we will non be accepting the pecuniary contribution from Dr. Doe. The infirmary does non desire to be scrutinized for accepting money that could be perceived as a payoff. nor do we desire promote the message that it is acceptable for people to purchase these variety meats. Lisa is a immature miss with possible and as modern medical specialty continues to progress. she has the chance to be a aid her society subsequently on in her life.