Nationalism In German Music During The Early

Romantic Period Essay, Research Paper

Until the 19th century, music was by and large regarded as an international linguistic communication. Folk music had ever been in topographic point and linked straight with peculiar parts. On a larger graduated table though, European music was a device for look through the application of Italian techniques and manners. In other words, its proficient vocabulary was Italian, and from the clip of the early Baroque, European music, in general, had evolved its manners and proficient devices from the developments of Italian composers. Furthermore, tribunal opera was about ever performed in Italian, whether in Dresden or in London, no affair who composed it or where it was performed. For illustration, in 1855, Queen Victoria suggested to Richard Wagner that he interpret his opera Tannhauser into Italian so that it could procure a production in London. Thus, European music, irrespective of where it was composed could be ( and was ) performed throughout Europe and understood through the common Italian bids, descriptions, and manners. It was unacceptable for most to compose in any other manner. The international thought began to fall in in the early 19th century as embattled states or states subjugated by a foreign encroacher began to believe of music as an look of their ain national individuality, personality, or as a manner of voicing national aspirations.

In Germany, the thoughts of patriotism were prevented from happening an mercantile establishment in the universe of political political orientation and alternatively found mercantile establishments in music. This started in a really elusive manor. Take for illustration the increasing usage, by Beethoven, of the German linguistic communication in his instructions in his music. In his Adieux Sonata ( op. 81a ) , Beethoven & # 8217 ; s farewell to the Archduke Rudolph, the maestro increasingly uses increasing sums of German in his instructions and by the 3rd motion, small Italian at all. Sonatas written a few old ages subsequently are designated for the Hammerklavier and non for the forte-piano, Italian for piano. Such elusive alterations in traditional composing way foreshadowed ever-increasing inclinations toward German chauvinistic thoughts in music. As Henry Raynor puts it, & # 8220 ; the Napoleonic invasions which turned Beethoven from a simple revolutionist into a loyal Austrian revolutionist seem to hold made him experience that his ain linguistic communication was a absolutely satisfactory manner of stating piano players how he wanted his music played. & # 8221 ;

These early feelings of patriotism, if non merely for Beethoven, stemmed from the old ages of integrity under the protections of Napoleon & # 8217 ; s Empire, which gave a considerable part of cardinal Europe ground to recognize their corporate similarities. This big country shared a common linguistic communication and historical bequest. Traditions were similar as were aspirations. Indeed, & # 8220 ; ? the composite that was to go the German Empire presented a more or less homogenous province, united by linguistic communication and civilization but forced by political organisation into political disunity? & # 8221 ;

However, the thought of German integrity had surfaced old ages earlier, long before the radical boundary lines of Central Europe were rationalized by Napoleon and before Beethoven & # 8217 ; s usage of German vocabulary for direction in his music. The outstanding German Enlightenment minds Johann Gottfried Herder and Johann Gottlieb Fichte had espoused that patriotism in Germany was found in the integrity of civilization and non in the political state of affairs of the part. Herder though that if the German-speaking universe obtained a integrity of civilization and instruction, political integrity would follow. More significantly, it was the personality of the German people or Volk and their consciousness of a common civilization that would make the less critical political integrity. Herder was concerned with the cultural character entirely in his patriotism. Besides, his trade name of philosophical patriotism was applicable to others, and non entirely Germans. Somewhat conversely, Fichte believed that a state was non simply the combination of people and a certain geographical country but was a religious integrity created through shared civilization and aspirations, a consequence of spiritual, societal, economic, and political force per unit areas. Fichte was 20 old ages younger than Herder and promoted a more intense trade name of German patriotism that surfaced subsequently in the 19th century. Of great importance though, Fichte, unlike Herder, & # 8220 ; attributed to the Germans an originality and a mastermind non possessed by other peoples. & # 8221 ; Conversely altogether is the thought of Hegel. His point of view was that the province, its policies, and the order it enforces were the lone incarnation of patriotism or national civilization. In other words, it was the responsibility of the province to guarantee the independency of the humanistic disciplines and have the province maintain the incarnation of national civilization. It can be assumed that this position was non appealing Beethoven or Wagner. Thus, the hit of cultural and idealistic patriotism with the aspirations of Napoleonic France efficaciously caused the German people to warrant the political actions of their swayers, if non to happen look in a political sense.

The German provinces were without a centre without Austrian influence, as the Congress of Vienna had refused any Austrian influence in Western Europe. This created a spread, which remained until the creative activity of the German Empire under Prussian leading. However, the cultural integrity that existed in Germany, the integrity of a common linguistic communication, national folklore and national traditions, which were claimed as the existent footing for national individuality harmonizing to Fichte and Herder, all set the background for a desire for political integrity. Therefore, the ideas of Hegel began to make a sense of urgency in the heads of many Germans, an urgency for political patriotism.

Harmonizing to Raynor, & # 8220 ; the result of this sense of national integrity thwarted by a threadbare, inhibitory political system underlay the yearning for national integrity which persisted until the creative activity of the German Empire. & # 8221 ; So, missing a cultural centre and capital, Germany expressed its singularity through music more than literature, art, or political constructions. The deficiency of national political integrity besides encouraged a national sense of lower status. The Germans had the sense of patriotism, no political mercantile establishment, and were surrounded by strong incorporate states such as Austria and France.

By the 1830 & # 8217 ; s, Wagner was convinced that he had been born to salvage German opera and felt he might carry through this through Italian lessons. Wagner & # 8217 ; s idea was, at its nucleus, entirely national. He was convinced that German opera composers had lost their ability to win over the Black Marias of the people. Harmonizing to an article in a Leipzig magazine of 1834:

& # 8220 ; We are excessively rational, excessively learned, to make warm human figures. Mozart could make so, but he animated his characters with the beauty of Italian vocal. Since we have come to contemn this, we have wandered further and further from the way that Mozart beat out for the redemption of our dramatic music. Weber ne’er knew how to manage vocal, nor does Spohr understand it much better. But vocal is the organ through which a human being can pass on himself musically ; and so long as this is non to the full developed, he lacks echt address. This is where the Italians have an tremendous advantage over us ; with them, beauty of vocal is 2nd nature. & # 8221 ;

For Wagner and other opera composers, the ultimate signifier for this national cultural integrity was opera and vocal. The ability to separate a national subject was a testament to the national music of a state. In this citation, Wagner is saying that the Italians are the best for this. In other words, the Italians are the authorization on making vocal that is at one time recognizable as Italian, much like we can acknowledge national melodic types today, and this is merely what German music, and opera, demands.

Wagner on occasion wrote blatantly chauvinistic plants, Marches, for illustration,

Huldingungs Marsch for King Ludwig II of Bavaria, or The Kaisermarsch, observing the German triumph over France in 1870. These plants celebrate the political patriotism that was non espoused by Wagner straight, and surely non found in other plants of his like The Ring, in which German mythology universalizes a patriotism that runs much deeper than its obvious political statements. In another work, The Mastersingers, Wagner depicts the Volk, themselves, as the defenders of artistic tradition and advancement. Therefore, Wagner becomes the spokesman for a motion begun old ages before by Fichte and Herder.

Nonetheles

s, if this German national manner is non, like other national manners, immediately recognizable as German, it had popular looks which may now look strange. For illustration, in 1863 the Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde in Vienna awarded a award to a Swiss adult male, Joachim Raff, for his first symphonic music. This symphonic music was titled An Das Vaterland, and included a instead interesting and reasonably elaborate plan:

? First Motion: Allegro. Image of the German character ; ability to surge to great highs ; inclination towards self-contemplation ; clemency and bravery as contrasts that touch and interpenetrate in many ways ; overpowering desire to be brooding.

? Second Motion: Allegro molto vivace. The out-of-doorss ; through German woods with horns naming ; through clearings echoing with common people music.

? Third motion: Larghetto. Return to the domestic fireplace, transfigured by love and the Muses.

? Fourth Motion: Allegro drammatico. Defeated desires to work for the integrity of the Fatherland.

? Fifth motion: Larghetto-allegro trionfalle. Plaint ; renewed glide.

It is the 4th motion that attracts attending, possibly more than the others, for the statement at manus. It is interesting to observe that this piece of music has meant small for more than one hundred old ages. It is rarely performed today and played even less on public wireless. At any rate, the of import thing is that the composer of this was from Zurich, educated in Germany, and a adult male who spent his full calling in Germany and chose a uniquely German subject for one of his first major plants. And, above that, he won a award for it. It is appearent that in Raff & # 8217 ; s mind that The Fatherland was a subject as of import and invigorating as any other battle witnessed in 19th century composing, be it life and decease, destiny, love, or mythology.

Patriotism in German music was ne’er a witting attempt to happen a national voice, for that already existed. Wagner and theses other composers sought to portray a national phenomenon that they believed already existed in all facets of life except the political. Another illustration can be witnessed in a work of Brahms. Born in Hamburg, where the history of independency, enjoyed by the old metropolis as a member of the Hanseatic League, outweighed any impressions of rank in a politically united Germany, lived in Vienna. Here the air was immensely different from the earnestness and emotional soberness of northern Germany. The Austro-Prussian War of 1866, left Austria defeated and deprived of all influence among any German provinces and saw the formation of the North German Confederation under Prussian leading. This left Brahms annoyed with both sides because he felt who would take a united Germany, either Prussia or Austria, was of small effect. It was the Franco-Prussian War of 1870 that truly stirred him. Harmonizing to Raynor, he told a friend, Georg Henschel, a celebrated singer-conductor, that his first urge was to fall in the Army. Besides, the great solon, Bismarck, had become an graven image to him. Brahms celebrated the triumph over France with a work entitled Triumphlied. This work, combing chorus and orchestra, used scriptural words to link the thoughts of German patriotism with Old Testament Hebrew nationalism.

This strong belief that German composers wrote music that existed on a much higher rational degree than the music of other states and contained the individualism of the composer was non new. Charles Burney wrote in the 1780 & # 8217 ; s of chauvinistic qualities in music, old ages before anyone idea of music as look of national qualities. However, by the 2nd one-fourth of the 19th century, composers bit by bit began to inquire if instrumentalists in other states could truly understand German music. In other words, the supposed rational highness of German music may be hard for other states to execute decently and with the right German spirit. Wagner noted this after public presentations of Beethoven symphonic musics by the Conservatoire Concerts Society Orchestra during his first stay in Paris. He was impressed by the public presentations, but felt that there were deeper inquiries that needed to be asked. The Gallic had performed these pieces accurately but with unfairness to the text of the music. He was surprised by the Gallic public presentations of Beethoven & # 8217 ; s strong German spirit:

& # 8220 ; They love to look up to and clap things beautiful and unknown from abroad. As to witness the response that has been so rapidly accorded to German instrumental music. Though, apart from this, whether one could state that the Gallic wholly understand German music is another inquiry, the reply to which must be dubious. Certainly it would be incorrect to keep that the enthusiasm evoked by the Conservatoire orchestra & # 8217 ; s public presentation of a Beethoven Symphony is affected. Yet when one listens to this or that enthusiast aerating the assorted sentiments, thoughts, and amour propres which a symphonic music has suggested to him, one realizes at one time that the German mastermind is far from being wholly grasped. & # 8221 ;

It is likely that examples of this same type of incomprehension could be found every bit every bit many times by German hearers at German public presentations of German plants. It is interesting to observe that Wagner wrote uncomprehendingly of Haydn & # 8217 ; s symphonic musics. Schumann and other coevalss found little more than elegance and beauty in Mozart & # 8217 ; s instrumental plants. Spohr and his coevalss found little in the latter plants of Beethoven that was easy gratifying.

Additionally, German instrumentalists felt that because their music was superior, if merely their heads, that they had already mastered the music of other states. The incomprehension witnessed in France by Wagner was non merely the strangeness of a different musical linguistic communication. Rather, it was the feeling that the Germans merely thought in music more profoundly than the instrumentalists of other states felt it necessary to make so. This is important for a clip when music, more than any other medium, was the mercantile establishment and cardinal consolidative force of a people non united politically.

The 19th century saw many more alterations than the move from international to national music. The illustrations used here of Germany are but a little fraction of this phenomenon that occurred in the states of all Europe during the century. Italy had its music patriotism, as did Hungary, Russia, and others. All of these states had their ain alone sets of fortunes and interesting composers. Other countries of music witnessed dramatic alterations that can be traced to the flicker of patriotism.

Merely as there were legion experiments in political relations across the continent, so to was there experimentation and invention in music during the century. The employment of new harmonic construction and rhythmic techniques to give orchestral music greater colour and strength was one of the greatest of these. New instruments were added and older 1s were redesigned to do them more heavy and flexible. Besides, different combinations of instruments were used to make new orchestral sounds. What & # 8217 ; s more, the cultural and political patriotism of the century created the political and cultural environment ( in a wide and general sense ) of the 20th century. The 19th century created the musical environment in which 20th century instrumentalists grew-up. The opera and concert organisations, the system of chamber music public presentations, and the alternate attractive forces of music comedy, assortment, and popular music in all its signifiers were developments of music phenomenon that first manifested themselves in the 19th century. & # 8220 ; In the 19th century, music was harnessed to the cause of patriotism, and played a function whose importance can likely ne’er be accurately assessed in stirring up nationalist feeling and making a national self-consciousness. & # 8221 ;

Breunig, Charles. The Age Of Revolution And Reaction, 1789-1850.New York:

W.W. Norton And Company, 1977.

Longyear, Rey M. Nineteenth Century Romanticism in Music. New Jersey: Prentice-

Hall, 1969.

Raynor, Henry. Music and Society, Since 1815. New York: Taplinger Printing

Company, 1978.

Rich, Norman. The Age of Nationalism And Reform, 1850-1890. New York: W.W.

Norton & A ; Company, 1977.

Roberts, J.M. A History of Europe. New York: Allen Lane, 1997.

Rowen, Ruth Halle. Music Through Sources And Documents. New Jersey:

Prentice-Hall, Inc. , 1979.