A Phony Family Essay Research Paper Mark

A Phony Family Essay, Research Paper

Mark Jason S. So March 1999

A & # 8216 ; Phony & # 8217 ; Family

Each and every action the kids performed in school and in any topographic point is a contemplation of the quality of life they have in their ain places. Parents have a duty of taking attention of their kids and parents have the influence and impact that creates the primary personality of an person. This influence can model a certain single into a responsible citizen or a rebellious delinquent as perceived in J.D. Salinger & # 8217 ; s & # 8220 ; The Catcher in the Rye & # 8221 ; .

The supporter, Holden Caulfield, interacts with many people throughout fresh, but likely none have every bit much impact on him as certain members of his immediate household. The ways Holden acts about or reacts to the assorted members of his household give the reader a direct position of Holden & # 8217 ; s doctrine environing each member and would probably explicate his actions in the narrative. Holden makes mention to the word & # 8220 ; phony & # 8221 ; 44 separate times throughout the novel ( Corbett, 1997 ) . Each clip he seems to be mentioning to the topic of this metaphor as & # 8212 ; person who discriminates against others, is a dissembler about something, or has manifestations of conformance ( Corbett, 1997 ) . Throughout & # 8220 ; The Catcher in the Rye & # 8221 ; , Holden describes and interacts with assorted members of his household. The manner he talks approximately or to each gives you some thought of whether he thinks they are & # 8220 ; phony & # 8221 ; or normal. From the really first page of the novel, Holden begins to mention to his parents as distant and generalise both his male parent and female parent often throughout his history. Holden & # 8217 ; s male parent is a attorney and hence he considers him & # 8220 ; phony & # 8221 ; because he views his male parent & # 8217 ; s business unswervingly as a analogue of his male parent & # 8217 ; s personality.

& # 8220 ; Lawyers are all right, I guess & # 8211 ; but it doesn & # 8217 ; t entreaty to me, & # 8217 ; I said. & # 8216 ; I mean they & # 8217 ; re all right if they go around salvaging guiltless cats & # 8217 ; lives all the clip, and like that, but you don & # 8217 ; t do that sort of material if you & # 8217 ; re a attorney. All you do is do a batch of dough and play golf and play span and purchase autos and imbibe Martinis and look like a hot-shot. How would you cognize you weren & # 8217 ; t being a hypocrite? The problem is, you wouldn & # 8217 ; t ‘ & # 8221 ; ( Salinger, 1945 ) .

When Holden describes his ma, he ever seems to make so with a sense of compassion yet besides with a scoffing tone. Holden makes his mom sound predictable and insincere. These bogus qualities are shown in two different illustrations when Holden is concealing in the cupboard of D.B. & # 8217 ; s room as his ma walks in to insert in Phoebe: & # 8216 ; Hello! & # 8217 ; I heard old Phoebe say. & # 8216 ; I couldn & # 8217 ; t slumber. Did you have a good clip? & # 8217 ; & # 8216 ; Marvelous, & # 8217 ; my female parent said, but you could state she didn & # 8217 ; t intend it. She doesn & # 8217 ; t bask herself much when she goes out. ? & # 8217 ; Good dark. Travel to kip now. I have a splitting concern, & # 8217 ; my female parent said. She gets concerns rather often. She truly does ( Salinger, 1945 ) . The first two illustrations are first-class illustrations of how Holden classifies people as hypocrites. However, when it comes to Holden & # 8217 ; s older brother, D.B. , more analysis is needed to deduce Holden & # 8217 ; s true feelings about his brother. Holden seems to esteem his older brother slightly but can non digest the imposed false image brought on by D.B. & # 8217 ; s career pick as a screen-play author. For illustration, this sense of regard is shown when D.B. takes Hold

nut and Phoebe to see Hamlet: “He treated us to lunch foremost, and so he took us. He’d already seen it, and the manner he talked about it at tiffin, I was dying as snake pit to see it, too” ( Salinger 1945 ) . Holden feels that all films and shows are false, absurdly overdone portraitures of world and later because his brother takes portion in these perversions of pragmatism, he is a “phony.”

The manner that Holden interacts with his sister, Phoebe, and the manner Allie & # 8217 ; s decease still affects Holden are two direct illustrations of the effects sibling relationships create. The relationships people portion with siblings are frequently the longest lasting they will of all time hold ( Crispell, 1992 ) . This thought, multiplied with the fact that Allie and Phoebe are immature and guiltless, is possibly why Holden has regard for his younger siblings and considers them the lone wholesome members of his household. Whenever Holden seems depressed ( which is rather frequently ) he tends to turn to his younger siblings for comfort and support. Even though Allie is no longer available for existent physical comfort, thought of him makes Holden experience better. These thoughts are shown in legion illustrations throughout the novel. When Holden cheques into the hotel and, while get downing to experience down, the first individual he wants to name is Phoebe but he decides non to because it is so late. & # 8220 ; But I surely wouldn & # 8217 ; Ts have minded hiting the old dirt with Phoebe for a piece & # 8221 ; ( Salinger, 1945 ) . Holden & # 8217 ; s ideas of Allie are shown with the fact that Holden wrote Stradlater & # 8217 ; s composing on & # 8220 ; Old Allie & # 8217 ; s baseball hand & # 8221 ; ( Salinger, 1945 ) . From Holden & # 8217 ; s history, it is obvious that he views the older members of his household as hypocrites and the younger members as icons of truth and artlessness. Yet seeking to wholly analyse how Holden genuinely thinks and feels about each member of his household is a undertaking that may non even be wholly possible.

Holden is the narrator in Salinger & # 8217 ; s novel. He tends to hold rebellious mode as reflected his isolation and purdah from society. Holden does non hold any friends and can non maintain relationships. These is because he finds and exaggerates any negative facet of all the people he knows or meet. These venerable features of Holden were a direct contemplation of what & # 8217 ; s his life in their place. The experiences he has at place where everlastingly be embedded in his head, puting a incorrect mentality for the lame apprehension of the storyteller. These influences from place had determined Holden & # 8217 ; s ain personality and his position of life and has molded what he is today. If Holden is a rebellious delinquent, it is because of the annihilating experiences and conditions he has in their place.

& # 8220 ; The Catcher in the Rye & # 8221 ; is a novel, which gives us some thought of how an stripling male child, confronting the common experiences and problems of day-to-day life, has been influenced by each member of his household.

Bibliography

Corbett, Edward P.J. & # 8220 ; Raise High the Barriers, Censors. & # 8221 ; 1997

Crispell, Diane. & # 8220 ; The Sibling Syndrome & # 8221 ; .1992

Salinger, J.D. & # 8220 ; The Catcher in the Rye & # 8221 ; . Little Brown and Company, Boston, USA. 1945

Corbett, Edward P.J. & # 8220 ; Raise High the Barriers, Censors. & # 8221 ; 1997

Crispell, Diane. & # 8220 ; The Sibling Syndrome & # 8221 ; .1992

Salinger, J.D. & # 8220 ; The Catcher in the Rye & # 8221 ; . Little Brown and Company, Boston, USA. 19